Three weeks ago, I spoke at Vinitaly in New York alongside three people who see the American wine market from very different vantage points: Francis Creighton, President and CEO of Wine & Spirits Wholesalers of America (WSWA); Bartholomew Broadbent, founder of the importer Broadbent Selections; and Robert Joseph, a wine expert and brand owner of numerous wines, most notably Le Grand Noir.
The panel, and the conference more broadly, focused on the challenges and opportunities facing Italian wineries seeking to enter the American market.
Many foreign wineries don’t understand the legal nuances of the American market. To the Italian wineries, there is nothing similar to the three-tier system in Europe. The Italian winery attempting to enter the American markets needs not only to understand the legal nuances of the three-tier system, but how it works from a business perspective.
From a legal perspective, Italian wineries deal with numerous distribution systems in the U.S. Some are government-controlled systems, some are franchise states, where the law sharply limits a supplier’s ability to terminate a wholesaler without good cause, and in other nonfranchise and non-control states, how the contract is written will determine what things look like if the relationship goes south.
As I stated to the Italian wineries, the contract with the U.S. wholesaler does not create a relationship it creates a marriage. In a relationship, if something goes wrong, you can pack up and leave. In a marriage if things go wrong, there are legal hurdles to jump through and steep costs you must incur. A contractual relationship with the wholesaler is more akin to the latter than the former.
From a business perspective, the present bottleneck of the three-tier system presents great obstacles for Italian wineries. How does an Italian wine distinguish itself when there is no other route to market and the system is already flush with thousands of already existing products?
The panel explored how Italian wineries could get traction in this hypercompetitive environment. With the odds stacked against a wine brand, the winery needs to create its own demand or convince the wholesaler the product will replenish itself and is worth investing in.
One approach that resonated is the winery’s ability to establish relationships with retailers and prove to the wholesaler that market demand exists.
If a winery wants to focus on a certain major market, it needs a presence in the market and needs to invest time and energy. And when the representative of the winery pays market visits to retailers, it shouldn’t be the head of sales, or some VP, but the owner of the winery that is involved in the nurturing of the wine and can tell the story of the winery. Without investment from this specific figure, many retailers believe they are being shortchanged and become more hesitant to engage with the winery.
A second major factor for driving demand is an online presence. If a consumer visits a winery in Italy and the American consumer cannot locate its wine in the American market, a potential special relationship between consumer and brand is lost.
By utilizing online marketplaces to locate wine and using SEO to drive their presence, Italian wineries have tools to increase their profile.
The moral of the story for Italian wineries is although forced upon them, the three-tier system will not act as a solution for selling wine. Obtaining American distribution does not mean the Italian winery has establish its presence or viability in the U.S. market. It just means the winery has a distributor that could help it out. But with a major bottleneck in the present system, and with the collapse of RNDC making the situation worse, a new Italian wine brand should not expect the distributor to be a partner in developing the market.
The Italian winery will often need to go at it alone to establish its market. To build a strong marriage with an American wholesaler, the Italian winery must work hard to make the marriage work. Vinitaly provided many excellent Italian family wineries with an opportunity to introduce their products to the American marketplace. I hope these wineries find great success in the coming years.
Leave A Comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.